The central feed
Review the context, examine the evidence and make your call. Percentages remain hidden until you vote.
102 matching debates
2008/09 · Semi-finals
Chelsea 1–1 Barcelona
Nicolas Anelka fell while running ahead of Éric Abidal, with limited visible contact.
2025/26 · Semi-finals
Atlético de Madrid 1–1 Arsenal
Arsenal's No4 handled the ball with his left arm away from his body.
2004/05 · Semi-finals
Liverpool 1–0 Chelsea
Luis García lifted the ball toward goal after Petr Čech challenged Milan Baroš, and William Gallas cleared near the line.
2023/24 · Group Stage
Paris Saint-Germain 1–1 Newcastle United
The ball deflected from Tino Livramento's chest onto his arm as he defended a cross.
2017/18 · Semi-finals
Real Madrid 2–2 Bayern München
Joshua Kimmich's cross struck Marcelo's arm shortly before half-time.
2008/09 · Semi-finals
Chelsea 1–1 Barcelona
The ball struck Gerard Piqué's raised arm as Anelka tried to move past him in the area.
2025/26 · Semi-finals
Atlético de Madrid 1–1 Arsenal
The referee initially judged that Atleti's No17 had fouled an Arsenal opponent.
2016/17 · Quarter-finals
Real Madrid 4–2 Bayern München
Marcelo carried the ball through the defence and squared for Ronaldo, whose position was disputed.
2017/18 · Quarter-finals
Real Madrid 1–3 Juventus
Gianluigi Buffon confronted referee Michael Oliver during the protests that followed the penalty award.
Germany 2006 · Round of 16
Italy 1–0 Australia
Fabio Grosso went down as Lucas Neill slid across his path in the final seconds.
Korea/Japan 2002 · Round of 16
Korea Republic 2–1 Italy
Damiano Tommasi broke through and finished, but the assistant referee had raised the flag.
Russia 2018 · Final
France 4–2 Croatia
Ivan Perišić's hand made contact with the ball as he defended a corner.
