IsFoul
PlayCrosswordDebatesWorld Cup 2026From the ArchivesFootball Files
IsFoul

Independent football verdicts, grounded in evidence and open discussion.

Think first. Compare after.

Explore

PlayCrosswordDebatesFrom the ArchivesFootball FilesAboutCommunity guidelines

Legal

Privacy noticeTerms of useCookie information

Language

© IsFoul. Built for informed football debate.

Sign inSign up

The central feed

Debates

Review the context, examine the evidence and make your call. Percentages remain hidden until you vote.

Filter debates

102 matching debates

Penalty decisionAwaiting your verdict
104'

UEFA EURO 2020 · Semi-finals

Inglaterra 2–1 Denmark

Was the extra-time penalty for contact on Sterling correct?

Raheem Sterling went down between Joakim Mæhle and Mathias Jensen after entering the area.

No votes yetNo comments yet
FoulAwaiting your verdict
62'

UEFA EURO 2012 · Group Stage

Inglaterra 1–0 Ukraine

Did Marko Dević's shot cross England's goal line?

John Terry cleared Dević's lifted shot after the ball appeared to cross the line.

No votes yetNo comments yet
FoulAwaiting your verdict
89'

UEFA EURO 2004 · Quarter-finals

Portugal 2–2 Inglaterra

Was Sol Campbell's late goal correctly disallowed?

Campbell headed the ball into the net as John Terry challenged goalkeeper Ricardo.

No votes yetNo comments yet
FoulAwaiting your verdict
78'

Copa América Brazil 2021 · Group Stage

Brazil 2–1 Colombia

Should play have stopped after the ball struck the referee before Brazil's goal?

A Brazilian pass struck referee Néstor Pitana before the move continued and Roberto Firmino scored.

No votes yetNo comments yet
Penalty decisionAwaiting your verdict
42'

USA 2024 · Group Stage

Brazil 1–1 Colombia

Should Brazil have received a penalty for Muñoz's challenge on Vinícius?

Daniel Muñoz tripped Vinícius Júnior in the area without first playing the ball.

No votes yetNo comments yet
Penalty decisionAwaiting your verdict
90+3'

2017/18 · Quarter-finals

Real Madrid 1–3 Juventus

Was the stoppage-time penalty for the challenge on Lucas Vázquez correct?

Medhi Benatia challenged Lucas Vázquez from behind as the winger prepared to finish near goal.

No votes yetNo comments yet
FoulAwaiting your verdict
4'

2004/05 · Semi-finals

Liverpool 1–0 Chelsea

Did Luis García's shot cross the goal line?

Luis García lifted the ball toward goal after Petr Čech challenged Milan Baroš, and William Gallas cleared near the line.

No votes yetNo comments yet
Penalty decisionAwaiting your verdict
24'

2008/09 · Semi-finals

Chelsea 1–1 Barcelona

Should Chelsea have received a penalty for Alves's challenge on Malouda?

Dani Alves challenged Florent Malouda close to the left edge of Barcelona's penalty area.

No votes yetNo comments yet
Penalty decisionAwaiting your verdict
56'

2008/09 · Semi-finals

Chelsea 1–1 Barcelona

Should Drogba have received a penalty for Abidal's challenge?

Didier Drogba went down while trying to finish under pressure from Éric Abidal and Yaya Touré.

No votes yetNo comments yet
Red cardAwaiting your verdict
66'

2008/09 · Semi-finals

Chelsea 1–1 Barcelona

Was Abidal's red card for the incident with Anelka correct?

Nicolas Anelka fell while running ahead of Éric Abidal, with limited visible contact.

No votes yetNo comments yet
HandballAwaiting your verdict
82'

2008/09 · Semi-finals

Chelsea 1–1 Barcelona

Should Chelsea have received a penalty for Piqué's handball?

The ball struck Gerard Piqué's raised arm as Anelka tried to move past him in the area.

No votes yetNo comments yet
HandballAwaiting your verdict
90+6'

2008/09 · Semi-finals

Chelsea 1–1 Barcelona

Should Chelsea have received a late penalty for Eto'o's arm contact?

Michael Ballack's shot struck Samuel Eto'o around the upper arm in added time.

No votes yetNo comments yet

Page 3 of 9

…
View debate
View debate
View debate
View debate
View debate
View debate
View debate
View debate
View debate
View debate
View debate
View debate
Previous
1
2
3
4
9
Next